New Strategies for Screening Job Candidates
Jeff Cronrod
Hiring managers today face more challenges in vetting job candidates than
detectives on “Law and Order” trying to uncover the truth in their latest
case. At least three resumes out of 10 are estimated to contain
falsehoods ranging from exaggerated job responsibilities to phony
credentials and even fabricated jobs. Many jobseekers have criminal
records, bad credit histories, workers compensation claims or other
baggage that is unlikely to come out in a job interview. And in this
post-September 11 era, there is always the possibility that a terrorist may
be lurking somewhere in the hiring pool.
Many organizations are responding to these grim realities by tightening
tried-and-true pre-employment screening processes as well as adding new
strategies for digging into prospects’ pasts. Soup-to-nuts background
checks that once were considered a nuisance and unnecessary expense
are now becoming standard operating procedure. Companies of all kinds
have stepped up their efforts to avoid unwittingly unrolling the corporate
welcome mat to applicants who may become an embarrassment — or
worse.
There is ample reason for concern. Last summer, for example, a
suburban Chicago school discovered that its principal had served federal
prison time for financial fraud. The man’s 1996 felony conviction for
fleecing AT&T in Milwaukee in a payroll alteration scheme had not shown
up in criminal background checks, in part because the two school systems
that employed him had failed to look for criminal records outside Illinois.
His misdeeds caught up with him only when he violated the terms of his
release.1
A few years ago, a Silicon Valley firm suffered a similar shock after hiring a
new vice president whose resume boasted a Ph.D. in engineering and a
prestigious appointment to a task force on Internet security. An
anonymous tip caused the company to double-check the claims. It turned
out that the task force did not exist, the “Ph.D.” was from an online diploma
mill, and the “doctor” did not even have a bachelors degree.2
Then there’s short-lived Notre Dame football coach George O’Leary, who
resigned after just five days on the job when he was caught in two lies
concerning a non-existent masters degree and three football letters he
never won.3 And the late James Baughman, one-time director of
recruitment for Lucent Technologies, who would never have gotten the job
if Lucent had known that he served time for embezzling money as a
California high school principal and also lied about earning a doctorate
from Stanford.4
These kinds of hiring mistakes can be prevented by applying some extra
shoe leather to the pre-employment screening process. Here are some
new and/or improved tools and techniques that are helping HR
professionals leave no stone unturned in determining which candidates
are — and are not — fit for employment.
National address trace
Arguably the most important new arrow in the hiring manager’s quiver, this
tool is gaining popularity because of its ability to improve the thoroughness
of criminal background searches. It involves surveying a series of national
databases — typically the three major credit bureaus and U.S. Postal
Service records, and sometimes others — to assemble an address history
on a given applicant. The results provide a road map to the local
jurisdictions that should be searched for possible criminal histories or any
other information that might call an applicant’s suitability or trustworthiness
into question.
This new breed of address verification is important for two related
reasons. First, even if an employer asks for prior addresses, the applicant
may inadvertently fail to provide a thorough list. Second, jobseekers with
skeletons in their closet may deliberately withhold addresses that will point
screeners to incriminating records. In both cases, a national address
trace will fill in the gaps.
10-year residence history form
Companies have always asked prospective new employees for a list of
prior addresses, but a few years of data was usually regarded as
sufficient. Now, even with the move to automated national address traces,
it is considered advisable to request that applicants voluntarily supply a
decade’s worth of domiciles. Any inconsistencies between the two sets of
addresses will raise a red flag that may help unearth a problematic past.
The availability of a longer address history also takes advantage of
changes in criminal databases. While public records used to date back no
more than seven years, many searches now retrieve information that is 10,
15 or even 20 years old. The longer the address trail, the greater the
chance of discovering an offense that might otherwise be overlooked.
Hybrid county/state/national criminal records searches
Standard pre-employment criminal background checks used to be limited
to manual searches in the applicant’s county of residence and/or
employment, largely because organizations did not see the value in paying
for more extensive electronic searches. In the wake of September 11 and
the adverse publicity frequently unleashed when an employee’s past
transgressions come to light, hiring managers are recognizing that a
combination of county, state and national research is necessary to fulfill
their due diligence obligations.
County records are fresher and more comprehensive in some respects
than broader databases (they contain both felonies and misdemeanors,
for example, while state records vary), but they are limited to crimes
committed within that county’s boundaries. State and national databases
lack up-to-dateness and the breadth of detail but they provide the
necessary geographic coverage, particularly when used in tandem.
One company learned the benefit of a combined state/national
examination quite by accident when the hiring director unintentionally
requested a national search on an applicant who had reported living in
Florida, California and New York. The state searches yielded nothing, but
the national search returned a hit indicating that the candidate had
committed an armed robbery in Arizona. Without checking the national
database, that employer would have hired a convicted felon.
Sex offender and terrorist databases
In addition to the usual checks for crimes like burglary, it is now possible to
broaden criminal background searches to encompass state databases of
registered sex offenders. Job applicants’ names can also be checked
against a list of accused terrorists, money launderers and international
drug traffickers compiled by the U.S. Treasury Department’s Office of
Foreign Asset Control from information provided by various national
security agencies.
These new search tools provide an additional layer of protection for fellow
employees as well as an extra means of defense against negligent hiring
suits.
Consistent education and employment verification
This is a case of an old practice that had fallen into disfavor in some
quarters and that is now enjoying a renaissance. In the dot-com boom
days, competition for talent was so fierce that there was little time for
thorough investigation of every contender. Many companies therefore
took applicants’ education and employment claims at face value and got
burned. Today HR personnel are viewing this step far more seriously,
knowing that failure to check an Ivy League degree or an
impressive-sounding job has come back to bite many of their colleagues.
Employment verification should include employment dates, position,
compensation, and rehire status. Education verification should cover
attendance, graduation date, course of study, degree, and grade point
average.
Internet-based outsourcing
Many HR departments have long outsourced pre-employment screening to
third-party services in order to free in-house personnel for other duties,
but the advent of the Internet has provided a new alternative with two
significant advantages: speed and 24x7 access.
The best of the newer Internet-based screening services deliver most
results in real time, aggregate all results into a single file, post reports
online for easy retrieval, update them as new information comes in,
archive them for several years, and allow employers to add their own
notes. Some services also handle manual tasks such as on-site county
records searches and verification of employment and education, providing
the one-stop shopping benefits of traditional services on top of the
immediacy of online access.
Beefed-up consent forms
This is listed last because it does not directly contribute to identifying the
persona non grata in a pile of resumes, but the necessary detective work
cannot even begin without it. Signed consent forms have been used for
years to authorize review of a job applicant’s credit records, but now they
must be expanded to protect employers against legal action related to
today’s wider-ranging background checks.
Consent forms should be updated to authorize examination of criminal
records, driving history, credit standing, educational records, financial
statements, professional licensure, workers compensation, military
compensation, and other areas, as well as personal interviews with
neighbors, friends, associates, and past and present employers.
Using these and other techniques to remove the bad apples from the
bushel will help avoid repercussions ranging from on-the-job theft to
negligent hiring suits and violent crimes. As the saying goes, it’s better to
be safe than sorry — particularly when the safety of the entire workplace
may be at stake.
1 “Ex-felon Winds Up a School Principal,” Chicago Tribune, July 20, 2003.
2 Information from company involved in the incident.
3 “Notre Dame Coach Resigns After 5 Days and a Few Lies,” New York
Times, December 15, 2003.
4 “Second Chance: Only After Recruiter’s Death Did Colleagues Learn of
His Past,” New York Times, March 5, 2001.
Articles
Finding Candidates
- 10 Reasons to Hire Vets
- Hire Older Workers
- Improving Candidate Quality
- Sourcing 101
- Sourcing Candidates Well
- Tips for Building Employment-Related Websites
- U.S. Employ of People with Disabilities: Free Workshops
- Virtual College Recruiting
Interviewing Basics
- 10 Commandments of Recruiting
- 5 Keys to Successful Hiring
- 7 Tips for Successful Phone Interviews
- Behavioral Interviewing Basics
- Contrary Evidence Questions
- Interview Questions: Do's and Don'ts
- Interviewing Opening and Closing Remarks
- Interviews: Common Weaknesses
- Mistakes Amateur Interviewers Make
- Phone Screen Interview Mistakes
- Probing Techniques Explained
- Screening Interviewing: Top 10 Red Flags
- Strengthen the Validity of Your Interviews
- Telephone Interviews: Basics
- Ten Bad Listening Habits of Interviewers
- Types of Interviews
- Typical Probes and Follow up Questions
- What Do Interviewers Need to Know to be Effective?
Interviewing Best Practices
- 7 Keys to Effective Selection Interviews
- A Closer Look at Behavior-Based Interviewing
- Advantages / Disadvantages of Interviewing
- Applying Core Competencies to Selection Interviews
- Are You Really a Behavior-Based Interviewer?
- Assessing Speaking and Listening Skills
- Best Practices in Interviewing Candidates
- Deadly Interview Mistakes
- Death by Interview
- Ensure Hiring Success in Every Situation
- Executive Assessment Should Be Mandatory
- Generational Interviewing
- Hiring Interview + Strategic Applicant Management
- Hold Evening and Off-Time Interviews
- How to Interview a Top Performer
- Improve your Interviewing Techniques
- Interview Questions to Assess Soft Skills
- Interviewing for Ethics
- Interviewing Millennials
- Interviewing: Business or Psychology
- Metrics Interview
- Peeling Back the Onion
- The Positives of Panel Interviews
- Time for Candidate Advocacy?
- Tips for Conducting Successful Interviews
- Two Critical Interviewing Questions
Laws & Documentation
- Applicant Reference Release
- At Will Employment Release
- Avoid Negligent Hiring Mistakes
- Employee Referral Program Metrics
- Fair Labor Standards Act Information
- Four Interview Questions Never to Ask
- Giving Employee References
- Hiring Compliance Guidelines
- Hiring for Small Business
- Interviewing People with Disabilities
- Job Denial Letter
- Legal Issues in Interviewing
- Minimize Employment Risks: Document
- SAMPLE Employment Policy
- SAMPLE Letter: Educational Records Check
- SAMPLE Letter: Reference Check
- Ten Safe Hiring Tools
- What is Negligent Hiring
Line Manager / Recruiting Partnership
- Defending Candidates to Hiring Managers
- Interlocking Core Competency Interviews
- Internal Application Process
- Making Internships Work for You
- Making the Case for Behavioral Interviewing
- Non-Traditional Merit Pay Alternatives
- OFCCP Definition of an Internet Applicant
- Why Managers Shouldn't Do Most Hiring
- Workforce Planning: Strategic Staffing Strategy
Post-Interview
Pre-Planning & Retention
- Bonus or Incentive?
- Brand-Building on a Budget
- Build a First-Rate Hiring Process
- Closing the Deal
- Compensation Plans: An Overview
- Conducting an Exit Interview
- Good Hiring Starts with a Good Job Profile
- Improve the Quality of the Employment Function
- Interview Process Problems
- Interview the Job Before the Candidates
- Job Description Template-Link Pay to Performance
- Linking Pay to Company Performance
- Selecting and Using Salary Surveys
- Succession Planning
- Succession Planning: Identifying Top Performers
- Using a Pre-Interviewing Questionnaire
- Winning the War for Talent
- Worker Shortage by 2010: Preparation
Reading the Candidate
- Beware of Those Who Boast
- Blind Man's Bluff
- Decision, Decisions: Choosing the Better Applicant
- Detecting Deceit in Interviews
- Little White Lies on Resumes
- Suspend Judgment Until the Interview is Over
Recruiting Basics
- College Recruiting Basics
- College Recruiting Essentials
- Cut Down on Interview No Shows
- Discouraging Low Quality Applicants
- Don't Hold Too Many Interviews
- Job Descriptions: Why are they Important?
- New Strategies for Screening Job Candidates
- Preventing Resume Overload with Questionnaires
- Resume Review Basics
- Test Validation Explained
- The Value of Person-Organization Fit
- Three Companies Cut Turnover with Tests
Recruiting Best Practices
- 25 Telltale Signs of the Wrong Candidate
- 5 Overlooked Ways to Hire Winners
- Asking the Right Recruitment Questions
- Attracting Your Competitor's Employees
- BPR.......for Recruiters!
- Candidate Engagement
- Cloud Recruiting
- Evaluate Your Capture Strategy
- Hiring Best Practices
- How Do You Attract and Retain the Best People?
- How to Attract Applicants to Undesirable Jobs
- How to Attract, Develop and Retain Best People
- How to Find and Keep Valued Employees
- Ignorance and the Human Condition
- Onboarding Success Secrets
- Secrets to Non-Profit Hiring
- Selecting Top Management Talent
- Semi-Active Candidates are Best Bets
- Six Core Selling Principles
- Skills Based Recruiting: When, not How
- Smart Choices: How to Hire the Best
- Strategy for Hiring the Best This Year
- The Uses and Misuses of Personality Tests
- Top 10 Employee Selection Mistakes & Solutions
- Treat Candidates with the Carbon Rule